Over the years, hockey has mostly been known for its Canadian players. But nowadays, it’s becoming more inclusive with players from all around the world joining in. Even though Canada has had a big influence, American players have always been important too, especially in the National Hockey League. Some of the best American hockey players have made significant contributions to the sport’s history and success. The ultimate roster of the finest best American hockey players in history includes these remarkable athletes.
Let’s embark on our journey into the achievements of the best American hockey players of all time, exploring the top 10 and acknowledging some other noteworthy mentions. Our evaluation will extend beyond their NHL accomplishments to encompass their impact in collegiate and international hockey. Without further delay, let’s begin delving into their achievements.
10. Auston Matthews
Although it might seem too quick to call someone one of the best American hockey players of all time after only five NHL seasons, Auston Matthews unquestionably secures his place on this prestigious list. Being the seventh American selected first overall, his exceptional ability to score goals was evident right from the beginning, highlighted by his remarkable debut of four goals—a feat unparalleled in the modern era.
Wrapping up his first season with an impressive 40 goals and 69 points, he secured the Calder Memorial Trophy with an overwhelming majority, receiving 164 out of 167 first-place votes. Auston Matthews undoubtedly earns his spot in the ultimate roster of the finest best American hockey players in history.
Matthews: A Dominant Force in American Hockey History
Matthews stands out as one of the best American hockey players. He consistently maintains a pace of scoring 40 goals in 82-game seasons, despite facing injuries and challenges from COVID-19. Notably, during the 2020-21 season, he showcased his dominance in the all-Canadian North Division by scoring 41 goals in just 52 games, earning him the prestigious Maurice “Rocket” Richard Trophy for being the league’s top goal-scorer.
This achievement places him among the top 20 NHL era-adjusted goal-scoring seasons. Furthermore, he earned the Hart Trophy as the league’s Most Valuable Player in 2022 after scoring 60 goals and accumulating 106 points in 73 games. These accomplishments firmly establish him as one of the best American hockey players.
Matthews Stands Out Among Top American Hockey Players
Matthews, the second-best American hockey player in terms of points per game, leads in goals per game played. He has amassed an impressive 537 points across 478 games. Although some express concern about his performance during playoffs, it is commonly understood that players need time to improve in this area. While some may feel it is too soon to rank Matthews so high among the best American hockey players, there is little doubt he is on track to reach the top by the end of his career, unless there are any major surprises. Considering his achievements thus far, it is fair to recognize him as the top player for now.
Honorable Mention: Keith Tkachuk
Matthew and Brady are the sons of a famous hockey player known as Big Walt. Matthew plays for the Calgary Flames, while Brady plays for the Ottawa Senators. In the NHL drafts of 2016 and 2018, Matthew was chosen as the sixth pick, and Brady as the fourth pick, respectively. People think that Matthew and Brady have the potential to be just as successful as their father, if not more.
Both Matthew and Brady are seen as future stars who could one day join the ranks of the ultimate roster of the finest best American hockey players in history. Apart from their hockey careers, Big Walt’s daughter, Taryn, is gaining recognition as an excellent field hockey player in the St. Louis region. Although Big Walt deserves acknowledgment for his achievements, in this comparison, Matthews (likely referring to Auston Matthews) is considered slightly better.
9. Hobey Baker
Baker was born in a place called Bala Cynwyd, which is in Pennsylvania, in the year 1892. When he got older, he went to a college called Princeton University. At Princeton, he was really good at two sports: football and another sport. In football, he was especially good at catching the ball and running with it, which is called punt returning. He set many records for the school in football. Because he was so good, Princeton won a big competition called the national championship in 1911. Baker’s skill and hard work were a big reason why Princeton did so well that year.
Baker: A Hockey Legend of Sportsmanship and Skill
Baker had a huge impact on hockey. He played a key role in Princeton winning two national championships in 1912 and 1914. During his time with the team, which lasted three seasons, he scored an impressive total of over 120 goals and provided more than 100 assists. What made him even more special was his sportsmanship. After every game, he would visit the dressing room of the opposing team and shake hands with each player, showing respect and kindness to everyone, regardless of the outcome of the match.
After finishing college, Baker joined the amateur St. Nicholas Club. In 1915, he won another national championship, but this time at the amateur level. Although the Montreal Canadiens of the National Hockey Association offered him a $20,000 contract to play for them, he decided to remain an amateur and turned down the offer.
Baker: Athlete, Brave Soldier, Sad Ending
Unfortunately, when World War I started, Baker had to go to another country to fight in the war. Even though it was a difficult time, he showed great skill and bravery. He became a captain and led a group of 26 pilots and 180 enlisted men. He received honors for his bravery, like the French Croix de Guerre medal. Sadly, right before he was supposed to come back home, he took one last flight. That flight ended in a crash, and he died when he was only 26 years old.
Baker was truly exceptional in more than just hockey and football; he possessed extraordinary talent as a scratch golfer, achieved remarkable success as an elite swimmer, and occasionally showcased his abilities as a track and field athlete. Many regarded him as one of the greatest American athletes of all time. However, despite his numerous accomplishments, his hockey career was relatively short, which is the primary reason he isn’t ranked higher on this list of great athletes.
8. Jonathan Rapid
Currently, Quick stands as one of the best American hockey players, holding the second position among American goalkeepers with 375 victories. He trails Ryan Miller by just 16 wins, a margin he’s likely to overcome comfortably prior to his retirement. His save percentage (SV%) stands at .911, placing him 13th in the rankings among the best American hockey players. Notably, Quick and Miller both secured silver with the U.S. Olympic team in 2010, despite Quick serving as a backup goalie during that campaign.
Jonathan Quick: Playoff Superstar and Outstanding Goalkeeper
What sets Quick apart from the other goalies is his outstanding performance in the playoffs. In 2012, he played unbelievably well, helping the Los Angeles Kings win their first Stanley Cup. He won an incredible 16 out of 20 games, had a save percentage of .946, and allowed only 1.41 goals per game. This amazing performance earned him the Conn Smythe Trophy, which is given to the most valuable player in the playoffs. Moreover, Quick led all goalies in shutouts for three years in a row: he had three shutouts in one playoff, three in the next, and two more in 2014, when he won his second Stanley Cup with the Kings.
7. Patricia LaFontaine
That one season alone showcased LaFontaine’s exceptional skills, making him worthy of recognition on this list. He earned numerous awards, including the regular season and playoff MVP titles, recognition as the offensive rookie of the year, the esteemed Mike Bossy Award (named after a player whose rookie goal record LaFontaine surpassed that season), acknowledgment as the best professional prospect, and the honor of being named the CHL Player of the Year. His remarkable achievements during that season truly set him apart.
Pat LaFontaine’s Hockey Journey in New York: Achievements and Legacy.
After completing his tenure in the QMJHL, Pat LaFontaine proceeded to pursue his hockey career exclusively within New York state. He joined three different NHL teams during his professional journey: the New York Islanders, the Buffalo Sabres, and the New York Rangers. Over the course of his career, which encompassed 865 games, LaFontaine showcased his skill by amassing an admirable total of 1,013 points. His stellar performance led to his selection for five All-Star Games and the esteemed honor of receiving the 1995 Bill Masterton Trophy. However, despite his achievements, LaFontaine’s career faced an untimely end due to a succession of concussions.
The goal he scored during the fourth overtime of Game 7 in the Patrick Division Semifinal of 1987 is etched in Islanders’ lore as a moment of immense significance. This particular goal remains a cornerstone of the team’s history, symbolizing resilience and determination. It’s remembered not only for its timing but also for the impact it had on the outcome of the game and the series as a whole.
Exceptional Achievements and Consistency: A Closer Look at the Hockey Career.
Over the course of his career, he showcased his remarkable talent by achieving two standout seasons where he surpassed the 100-point mark in scoring, cementing his place among the best American hockey players. Among these notable seasons was 1992-93, during which he achieved an extraordinary total of 148 points. This achievement stands as a testament to his exceptional skill and dedication to the game.
Furthermore, his consistency in goal-scoring was evident through an impressive streak spanning six consecutive seasons from 1987 to 1993, during which he netted 40 or more goals each year. This consistency speaks volumes about his ability to perform at the highest level over an extended period.
Even beyond these six prolific seasons, he continued to demonstrate his scoring prowess, extending the streak to a seventh season in 1995-96. This extension of his goal-scoring streak further solidified his legacy as one of the best American hockey players and one of the most formidable offensive players in Islanders’ history, leaving an indelible mark on the sport and the team he represented.
Throughout his illustrious career, LaFontaine achieved a remarkable milestone, averaging a record-setting 1.17 points per game, a feat unparalleled by any other American player. Recognizing his outstanding contributions to the sport, he was inducted into the prestigious Hockey Hall of Fame in 2003 and later acknowledged as one of the NHL’s 100 greatest players in 2017, solidifying his place in hockey history. Even after retiring from professional play, LaFontaine’s dedication to athleticism remains unwavering. He has successfully completed numerous Ironman triathlons, demonstrating his enduring commitment and exceptional skills as an athlete, thus deserving the highest acclaim and recognition.
6. Neal Broten.
After the Dallas Stars moved to Dallas, Broten continued playing with them for another one and a half seasons before they traded him to the New Jersey Devils in February 1995. This trade turned out to be a huge success for him because he played a crucial role in the Devils’ surprising victory over the heavily favored Detroit Red Wings in a four-game sweep to win the Stanley Cup. What’s remarkable is that Broten scored the goal that clinched the series, making him the first-ever American to do so. It’s interesting to note that Viacheslav Fetisov, who was a member of the 1980 Soviet team, was on the ice playing for the opposing team during that historic moment.
Broten’s achievements distinguish him as one of the best American hockey players. He clinched an NCAA championship while playing for the University of Minnesota, earned an Olympic gold medal, and secured a Stanley Cup victory, solidifying his place among the top-tier athletes in the sport. His pivotal moment came with the game-winning goal in the NCAA Championship, which further underscored his prowess on the ice. Additionally, in 1981, he was honored with the prestigious Hobey Baker award, further cementing his legacy as one of the best American hockey players of his time.
Legacy of a Hockey Legend: The Remarkable Career and Achievements.
Despite retiring in 1997, he managed to accumulate six points across three games during a short-lived comeback with the U.S. Team in the 1999 Ice Hockey World Championship. This remarkable feat further solidified his status as one of the best American hockey players. Subsequently, he received the honor of being inducted into the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame in 2000. Additionally, his jersey number 7 was retired by the Stars, a testament to his outstanding contributions to the team. Furthermore, in 2009, he was acclaimed by Minnesota fans as the greatest player ever to emerge from the state, further enhancing his reputation among the best American hockey players.
5. Brian Leetch
During his long career, which spanned 1,205 games, Brian Leetch played for teams other than the Rangers only 76 times. In those games, he scored 247 goals and made 781 assists, totaling an impressive 1,028 points. As a rookie, he performed exceptionally well, earning 71 points and winning the Calder Trophy after receiving 42 out of 63 first-place votes. Later in his career, he also won two Norris Trophies in the seasons of 1991-92 and 1996-97, which further showcased his outstanding skills as a defenseman in hockey.
Brian Leetch: Winning Big with the Conn Smythe Trophy and More.
In 1994, a significant achievement was added to his collection of trophies: the Conn Smythe Trophy. This award is given to the Most Valuable Player (MVP) of the postseason. His exceptional performance during the playoffs, where he scored 11 goals and accumulated 34 points in 23 games, made him stand out. As a result, he earned the distinction of being the very first American player to win the esteemed Conn Smythe Trophy.
Throughout his illustrious career, Leetch made appearances in nine All-Star games, claimed a silver medal in 2002, and formally concluded his playing days in 2007. The Rangers retired his number 2 jersey the subsequent year, coinciding with his induction into the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame. Shortly thereafter, he earned his place in the Hockey Hall of Fame. Yet, perhaps the true measure of Leetch’s impact lies in the sentiments expressed by his teammate Mark Messier in his NHL 100 greatest players video.
Mark Messier’s tribute to Brian Leetch.
He’s a part of the Hockey Hall of Fame and also the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame. Right now, he’s working as an assistant coach for the Arizona Coyotes. Before that, he was the head coach for the Buffalo Sabres for a while.
4. Cammi Granato
Granato achieved remarkable success in women’s ice hockey, particularly at the IIHF Women’s World Championship. She won a gold medal in 2005 and earned an impressive eight silver medals between 1990 and 2004. Additionally, she excelled at the Four Nations Cup, winning gold in 1997 and 2003, and securing silver five other times. Her achievements showcase her exceptional talent and dedication to the sport.
Granato’s Stellar Career: A Closer Look at Her Remarkable Achievements.
Cammi Granato: A Legacy of Leadership and Achievement in U.S. Women’s Hockey.
Oliver continued, stating that Cammi Granato had an impressive span of 15 years as a valued member of the U.S. Women’s National Team, starting her journey with the team in 1990. During her tenure, Granato made significant contributions to the team’s success, emerging as the leading scorer in the program’s history.
She accomplished this remarkable feat by accumulating a total of 343 points, comprising 186 goals and 157 assists, across 205 games played. Furthermore, Granato’s leadership qualities were evident as she held the esteemed position of captain for both the Nagano and Salt Lake City squads, demonstrating her influence and dedication to the team’s goals.
3. Patrick Kane
Many readers likely know more about Kane’s successes than those of other players listed here. But let’s delve into why they’re impressive: Kane scored 72 points in his first season, which earned him the Calder Trophy, a prestigious award for rookies. He outshone notable players like Nicklas Backstrom, Carey Price, and even his teammate Jonathan Toews. Not stopping there, Kane scored a crucial goal in overtime during Game 6, securing the victory and paving the way for his first of three Stanley Cup wins in 2010. And in 2013, he received the Conn Smythe Trophy for his outstanding performance, leading the Blackhawks with 19 points in 23 games.
Kane’s Stellar Career: From Record-Breaking Seasons to Resounding Achievements and Legacy.
During the 2015-16 season, Kane delivered an outstanding performance, scoring an impressive 46 goals and making 60 assists. His remarkable play earned him several prestigious awards. These awards included the Hart Memorial Trophy, given to the league’s Most Valuable Player (MVP), the Ted Lindsay Award, which fellow players voted him as the Most Outstanding Player, and he also secured the distinction of being the very first American player to win the Art Ross Trophy, awarded to the player leading the league in points during a single season.
eciding on Brett Hull’s Honorable Mention: Why We Chose Not to Include Him.
It was really difficult to decide whether to give Brett Hull an Honorable Mention because we had to carefully consider his status as the fourth-highest goal scorer in NHL history among American players, which is significant. Despite our careful deliberation, we ultimately chose not to include him on the list. However, we believed it was important to clarify why we made that decision.
Hull was born in Belleville, Ontario, in 1964. However, when he was young, his family moved around quite a bit because his dad, Bobby, played hockey for the Blackhawks team in the United States. So, Hull spent his early years in different places across the U.S. When he was just four years old, he started playing hockey himself.
Bobby’s Story: From Moving to the Winnipeg Jets to Playing Hockey in College.
But things changed when Bobby got traded to the Winnipeg Jets. This meant the family moved back to Canada. Even though they moved again, Hull didn’t stop playing hockey. He kept practicing and getting better, still following his love for the sport.
Eventually, after finishing high school, Hull decided to go to college at the University of Minnesota-Duluth. That’s where he continued his education while also playing hockey at a higher level.
Choosing Whether to Include Hull as a Top American Hockey Player.
While spending time in that place, Hull made a firm commitment to competing on the international stage. Even though Team Canada didn’t select him, he saw an opportunity to play for the American team and took it. As he continued his career, he stayed true to the American squad, recognizing that neither national team felt like his own in particular; he just decided to play where he had the chance.
2. Mike Modano
Mike Modano isn’t just any player for the Dallas Stars; he’s one of their biggest legends. But his impact goes beyond his team. He’s also one of the greatest American players in hockey history. Let’s break it down: Mike played a whopping 1,499 games, which is second only to American-born forwards.
He’s also tops among American NHL players in goals (561), points (1,374), and playoff points (146). Originally from Livonia, Michigan, Mike made a name for himself as a teenager in the Canadian Hockey League. However, despite playing for Canadian teams at one point, his heart always stayed true to his American origins. Mike Modano’s exceptional career secures his place in the ultimate roster of the finest best American hockey players in history.
This decision caused quite a stir because some people believed that older, more experienced players like Makarov shouldn’t be eligible for the Calder Trophy, which is typically awarded to younger rookies. In response to the controversy, the NHL changed the rules for the Calder Trophy the following year, making players older than 26 ineligible for the award.
Modano’s Remarkable Career: Overcoming Challenges and Achieving Greatness.
Modano stands out as the greatest player ever to grace the Stars’ franchise, whether in its Minnesota roots or its Dallas incarnation. In a momentous gesture, his revered number 9 jersey was retired in 2014, coinciding with his prestigious induction into the Hockey Hall of Fame. A testament to his unparalleled skill and dedication, he holds numerous records for the Stars, including most games played, highest goal tally, most assists, and the highest overall points tally. Modano’s impact transcends borders, as he rightfully claims the title of the greatest American forward in the sport’s storied history.
1. Chris Chelios
When considering American athletes, few can match the long-lasting career and accomplishments of Chris Chelios, who grew up in Chicago. Chelios played as a defenseman in hockey and is widely regarded as one of the best to ever play the game in that position. Due to his exceptional skill, dedication, and success on the ice, many believe that he deserves to be ranked right at the top among the greatest players in hockey history.
Chelios holds the impressive title of being eighth in the history of the NHL for the most games played, which is the highest among American players. Over the course of 1,651 games, he managed to score 185 goals and assist in 763, summing up to a grand total of 948 points. Notably, he also ranks 18th in career plus/minus, with an outstanding plus-351.
Chelios: Wins and Awards in Hockey.
Chelios’s contributions to hockey extended beyond individual awards. He helped the team win the Silver Medal in 2002 and played a pivotal role in securing gold at the 1996 World Cup of Hockey. However, his three Stanley Cup victories highlight the pinnacle of his career. He won his first with the Montreal Canadiens in 1986, the team that drafted him and where he began his professional journey. Later, he clinched two more Stanley Cup triumphs with the Red Wings in 2002 and 2008, cementing his legacy as one of the greatest defensemen in NHL history.
Chris Chelios: A Long Hockey Career and Lasting Impact.
Chris Chelios had a long career in hockey that lasted for four decades. It all began when he was selected in the draft in 1981 and officially started playing professionally in 1983. He continued to play in the National Hockey League (NHL) until April 6, 2010, which marked his final game with the Atlanta Thrashers. Chelios’s enduring presence and remarkable achievements secure his place in the ultimate roster of the finest best American hockey players in history.
After retiring from playing, Chelios received a great honor. Three years later, he was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame. This prestigious recognition came along with his former teammate Brendan Shanahan, who also played for the Detroit Red Wings.
But Chelios didn’t just walk away from hockey after retiring. He remained involved in the sport. He took on roles within the management of both the Red Wings and the Chicago Blackhawks. Even though he wasn’t on the ice anymore, his influence and contributions to hockey continued to be significant, making him an important figure in the hockey community.
The days ahead look good.
Ten years from now, significant changes are likely to occur in the landscape of the best American hockey players. Emerging players will shape the scene, and there is hope for numerous international achievements. There has never been a more exciting time to support the best American hockey players.