The complaint was filed without highlighting any particular statement from the interview as objectionable. No specific lines were identified that could support the concerns raised Operation Sindoor.
Voicing opinions about Operation Sindoor led to the arrest of Professor Ali Khan, a Muslim academic in India. This decision has sparked widespread debate among civil rights groups and the Indian media, many of whom see the sedition charges as unjustified.
The recent arrest of Professor Ali Khan has drawn significant attention in India. He was taken into custody after speaking about Operation Sindoor. This move has sparked strong criticism from civil rights organizations.
Several Indian news outlets have also expressed doubt about the charges. Many are questioning the basis for accusing him of sedition. The case has ignited an important debate about free speech and fairness in the country Operation Sindoor.
Many right-wing commentators have recently praised Colonel Sofia Qureshi, a fact that Professor Khan acknowledged in his social media post on May 8.
He suggested that these supporters could also use their influence to defend those harmed by mob violence, home demolitions, and the BJP’s politics of division. According to him, it’s important that all citizens receive equal protection and respect, regardless of their background.
A Few Words Online, A Big Problem in Real Life
The social media message sparked legal action, leading to an official complaint. The charges claim the post contained content harmful to the country and showed disrespect toward Indian women.
Questions arose about the complaint when Renu Bhatia, Chairperson of the Haryana State Women Commission, could not identify any specific part of the professor’s post as offensive or seditious during an interview. This brings into doubt the validity of the claims she had made.
My statement re the summons that I received from the Haryana State Women’s Commission.
The posts that were misunderstood and objected to can be accessed at these links:https://t.co/RMbrnmOCSQ
And https://t.co/Bkw7hwzs7f pic.twitter.com/dy9yivyUVn
— Ali Khan Mahmudabad (@Mahmudabad) May 14, 2025
When questioned, Renu Bhatia struggled to provide a clear answer. Although she argued that comments against women in the armed forces damage their dignity, she was unable to highlight any particular phrase from Professor Khan’s post that supported her claim. This left her position open to doubt.
She said she couldn’t believe anyone would make such comments. Instead of giving a clear explanation, she gave only vague and uncertain answers.
As the interview continued, Bhatia struggled to give clear answers about Professor Khan’s remarks. She failed to point out any specific words that offended Colonel Sofia Qureshi or Wing Commander Vyomika Singh. Frustrated, the anchor reminded her, Everyone is waiting to understand exactly what you heard. Still, she avoided giving a direct response.
The whole situation quickly became a public joke. A viral cartoon captured the absurdity by showing how senior officials ordered authorities to find something offensive in Professor Ali Khan’s post.
After that, the police focused on investigating his religion. Instead of looking for facts, the government’s response was simply to arrest him. This highlighted how unreasonable and unfair the entire process had become in the context of Operation Sindoor.
